Posted: Fri May 24, 2013 3:51 pm
What other reviews are there?chronical wrote:why are there so many reviews up today. I want to hear it too
What other reviews are there?chronical wrote:why are there so many reviews up today. I want to hear it too
Kind of harsh. I liked being able to get an idea of the album as it made me more excited. But ultimately, a music writer can't hear the same stuff that we hear. I think reviews and opinion pieces, if not uselessly negative and petty, can be like talking to a friend or an acquaintance at the record store. It gives us a wider perspective on the music's impact and an insight on how people process such weird and wonderful sounds.The Spaniard wrote:Oh, that is great. I do not need to buy the LP anymore, as now I have an opinion about it.
Obviously reviews like this don't convey the reality of a track when it hits your eardrums. But if it tells me that a particular track is beatless, and I didn't know that track was going to be beatless until I read the review, then it is a spoiler in the sense that I am now expecting a beatless track rather than discovering this myself upon first listen. It isn't exactly "spoiling" the song in any way, it is just giving away information that some people would rather discover first hand.Geogandhi wrote:I'd like to know how how these reviews are considered spoilers. All they say is whether they have beats or are drones etc etc. how can a few words relay the reality of it when it hits your eardrums.
However it does make it sound very promising hehe
I was being sarcastic. I totally agree with you.energywarning wrote:Kind of harsh. I liked being able to get an idea of the album as it made me more excited. But ultimately, a music writer can't hear the same stuff that we hear. I think reviews and opinion pieces, if not uselessly negative and petty, can be like talking to a friend or an acquaintance at the record store. It gives us a wider perspective on the music's impact and an insight on how people process such weird and wonderful sounds.The Spaniard wrote:Oh, that is great. I do not need to buy the LP anymore, as now I have an opinion about it.
Sarcasm never looks quite right over text, does it? With the exception of Jonathan Swift, perhaps.The Spaniard wrote:I was being sarcastic. I totally agree with you.energywarning wrote:Kind of harsh. I liked being able to get an idea of the album as it made me more excited. But ultimately, a music writer can't hear the same stuff that we hear. I think reviews and opinion pieces, if not uselessly negative and petty, can be like talking to a friend or an acquaintance at the record store. It gives us a wider perspective on the music's impact and an insight on how people process such weird and wonderful sounds.The Spaniard wrote:Oh, that is great. I do not need to buy the LP anymore, as now I have an opinion about it.
I have not read it, and I do not want to read it. Actually, I have not listened to all of my BoC songs even though I have bought the albums, as I want to get surprised and get happy discovering new songs. I always listen to the same songs, but when something special (very good or very bad) occurs in my life, I go and randomnly pick up a new song ( BoC song I have never heard before). Only one. Then I add that song to my list of BoC songs I am allowed to listen to. Every BoC song is like a very beautiful present for me.
And, as you can imagine, I am not going to listen to the whole TH even though I have bought the record.
The Spaniard.
It is true that sarcasm is sometimes hard to get on forums, but I thought it was obvious to think that I was kidding, that is why I wrote that. It was not my intention to confuse anybody.energywarning wrote:Sarcasm never looks quite right over text, does it? With the exception of Jonathan Swift, perhaps.The Spaniard wrote:I was being sarcastic. I totally agree with you.energywarning wrote: Kind of harsh. I liked being able to get an idea of the album as it made me more excited. But ultimately, a music writer can't hear the same stuff that we hear. I think reviews and opinion pieces, if not uselessly negative and petty, can be like talking to a friend or an acquaintance at the record store. It gives us a wider perspective on the music's impact and an insight on how people process such weird and wonderful sounds.
I have not read it, and I do not want to read it. Actually, I have not listened to all of my BoC songs even though I have bought the albums, as I want to get surprised and get happy discovering new songs. I always listen to the same songs, but when something special (very good or very bad) occurs in my life, I go and randomnly pick up a new song ( BoC song I have never heard before). Only one. Then I add that song to my list of BoC songs I am allowed to listen to. Every BoC song is like a very beautiful present for me.
And, as you can imagine, I am not going to listen to the whole TH even though I have bought the record.
The Spaniard.
This sounds like an ever growing, organic Boards of Canada reference point to match your own growth. That's very new, but interesting to think about.