Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Moderator: Aesthetics

User avatar
Skimming Stone
Eagle Minded
Posts: 449
Joined: Mon Nov 10, 2014 7:35 pm
Location: England

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Skimming Stone »

Jango9 wrote:I think you should be fine as long as you're not doing something like this:


1. Aquarius
2. An Eagle In Your Mind (there's a pretty decent original piece at the beginning of this one)
3. Pete Standing Alone
4. Kaini Industries
5. Rue The Whirl
6. The Color Of The Fire
7. Telephasic Workshop
8. Constants Are Changing (With synths instead of guitars, which represents an interesting possibility)
9. [Nothing immediately comes to mind]
10. Smokes Quantity

As for what you've got here, in my mind the closest BoC relative would probably be In The Annexe, which it doesn't actually sound that much like. I think you're doing fine.
That whole album is by far the funniest BoC ripoff I have ever heard. It's like he just heard MHTRTC for the first time and thought "I could do that!".
User avatar
Cupz
High Scorer
Posts: 10649
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:15 pm

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Cupz »

There are only a limited amount of chord progression, and even less chord progressions that sound absolutely amazing. You wouldn't believe how many musical pieces are written on the same chords. Take the circle of fifths as an example, a holy progression, tons and tons of songs based on it. Its what you do with the progression that's important. Don't be afraid to steal progressions if you have a new and fresh idea of what to do with them, or like it especially and want to toy around with it. Nobody owns them, even though plenty of people pretend they do. Music belongs to God if anyone. Why not go a step further and say you shouldn't be using the same scales as everyone else, or same 12 keys on the piano for that matter? It will never end. Just play the damn music, sonny, and make it sound tasty.
Throw away your smartphone.
User avatar
The Telepathic Kid
Happy Cycler
Posts: 3051
Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 12:26 pm
Location: Australia
Contact:

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by The Telepathic Kid »

start using quartertones tbh
User avatar
Cupz
High Scorer
Posts: 10649
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:15 pm

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Cupz »

Quarter tones are very awesome. Same rules apply, there are still a finite number of powerfull progressions.

Besides its difficult to do catchy, memorable stuff with quarter tones as they complicate things exponentially, which is the reason I personally don't use them often (besides not having the instruments to quarter-jam with). I feel they are not so well suited for sing-a-long-songs for example.
Throw away your smartphone.
drillkicker
Sherbet Head
Posts: 879
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 3:58 pm

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by drillkicker »

Cupz wrote:Why not go a step further and say you shouldn't be using the same scales as everyone else, or same 12 keys on the piano for that matter? It will never end. Just play the damn music, sonny, and make it sound tasty.
I'd really like to compose music using Indian notes and progressions, but it doesn't seem possible on the Eurocentric music software (and hardware) we have, unless anyone has a really unfathomable amount of time and dedication to patch it into Max.
Image
Auditor
Posts Quantity
Posts: 106
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2016 1:51 am

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Auditor »

You can get microtonality out of a lot of cheapish keyboards these days. My trusty esq-1 that I nabbed off ebay for $250 can do some simply astounding things. Had an old casio something or other that could do it as well
User avatar
Goiter Sanchez
Dayvan Cowboy
Posts: 1520
Joined: Thu Aug 11, 2005 7:39 am
Location: San Francisco, California
Contact:

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Goiter Sanchez »

Cosmic Manta wrote:Hey everyone!
I was working on a song, when I started to worry that the chord progression I was using was too similar to something BoC used, as it sounded a bit familiar. Any ideas as to what it is? Or am I just worrying about nothing? http://puu.sh/mgtv5/894e1aad12.mp3
Progression sounds similar to '1986 Summer Fire', if anything.
I make music as Sweguno.
InstagramYouTubeSoundcloud
User avatar
chronical
Sherbet Head
Posts: 750
Joined: Sun Apr 21, 2013 3:53 pm

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by chronical »

Sounds more like Daft Punk than BOC imo.
Image
User avatar
Cupz
High Scorer
Posts: 10649
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:15 pm

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by Cupz »

Oh I didn't even listen to op's mp3...

No.

and no.
Throw away your smartphone.
User avatar
DEVICE
Posts Quantity
Posts: 105
Joined: Fri Aug 27, 2010 11:42 am
Location: UK

Re: Is this chord progression too similar to a BoC song?

Post by DEVICE »

Jango9 wrote:I think you should be fine as long as you're not doing something like this:

Fun fact: Just about every song on this album rips off a BoC song to some degree

1. Aquarius
2. An Eagle In Your Mind (there's a pretty decent original piece at the beginning of this one)
3. Pete Standing Alone
4. Kaini Industries
5. Rue The Whirl
6. The Color Of The Fire
7. Telephasic Workshop
8. Constants Are Changing (With synths instead of guitars, which represents an interesting possibility)
9. [Nothing immediately comes to mind]
10. Smokes Quantity

As for what you've got here, in my mind the closest BoC relative would probably be In The Annexe, which it doesn't actually sound that much like. I think you're doing fine.
Bloody hell. The drum patterns sound almost identical in parts!
Post a reply