How many members were there before the dynamic duo?

youregonnaloveit! · Post by **youregonnaloveit!** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 5:48 pm

I read somewhere there were 3???? Correct me if im wrong

Fireal420 · Post by **Fireal420** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 5:51 pm

yeah, there were apparently 3 members. the third being the founder of the band christ.

whenever you have questions about BOC just go to, http://bocpages.org/wiki/About

that site has just about every bit of info you can possibly find on BOC

youregonnaloveit! · Post by **youregonnaloveit!** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 5:53 pm

Thanks

harpoon dodger · Post by **harpoon dodger** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 8:43 pm

There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.

zeoevil · Post by **zeoevil** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 11:42 pm

harpoon dodger wrote:There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.

At this point, I think it comes down to finding the other members and dealing with the legal ramifications of releasing the old material. If they just threw it out there all willy-nilly, they could open themselves up to trouble. They might not even be able to find some of those people so the possibility that we might hear all of Duffy or Infinite Sevens or "insert your favorite here" is effectively null.

youregonnaloveit! · Post by **youregonnaloveit!** » Wed Feb 13, 2013 11:52 pm

zeoevil wrote:
harpoon dodger wrote:There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.
At this point, I think it comes down to finding the other members and dealing with the legal ramifications of releasing the old material. If they just threw it out there all willy-nilly, they could open themselves up to trouble. They might not even be able to find some of those people so the possibility that we might hear all of Duffy or Infinite Sevens or "insert your favorite here" is effectively null.

So in other words, no official release of old tunes and beyond?:(

Post by **mdg** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 11:33 am

zeoevil wrote:
harpoon dodger wrote:There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.
At this point, I think it comes down to finding the other members and dealing with the legal ramifications of releasing the old material. If they just threw it out there all willy-nilly, they could open themselves up to trouble. They might not even be able to find some of those people so the possibility that we might hear all of Duffy or Infinite Sevens or "insert your favorite here" is effectively null.

Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

PadraïK · Post by **PadraïK** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 12:15 pm

mdg wrote:
zeoevil wrote:
harpoon dodger wrote:There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.
At this point, I think it comes down to finding the other members and dealing with the legal ramifications of releasing the old material. If they just threw it out there all willy-nilly, they could open themselves up to trouble. They might not even be able to find some of those people so the possibility that we might hear all of Duffy or Infinite Sevens or "insert your favorite here" is effectively null.

Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

thank you for the clarification there Mr. G. Happy to read between the lines

Negamuse · Post by **Negamuse** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 12:34 pm

mdg wrote:
Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

This post has made me very happy.

harpoon dodger · Post by **harpoon dodger** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 6:47 pm

Thanks for the clarification MDG..kinda dorking out you quoted me lol. I never assumed that other "members" shared credit for songwriting, clearly BoC is the Sandison's baby and anyone else involved merely 'played their part'. Cool to know!

GH · Post by GH » Thu Feb 14, 2013 7:51 pm

If the early stuff ever does come out, it will be called A Few Really Fucking Old Tunes.

bluesky · Post by **Fredd-E** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 8:18 pm

Thanks MDG for yet another helpful insight. /cheers

northernlite · Post by **northernlite** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 8:41 pm

Wow, that's nice to hear

I can die happy if we ever get to hear the full version of 'Wouldn't You Like To Be Free?'

warphead · Post by **warphead** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 9:13 pm

'dynamic' duo

sorry but that made me laugh (in a nice way)

It's interesting to hear that mdg mentions it takes a long time remastering and curating old material.....

Evrox · Post by **Evrox** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 9:54 pm

mdg wrote: Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

Hello Mike or Marcus!

hexagon son · Post by **hexagon son** » Thu Feb 14, 2013 10:59 pm

Yet again, someone is peeking into our bedroom window to see if we are ready or not. I better not be unemployed when new (or old) music is released. I need the cash to throw down!

GH · Post by GH » Fri Feb 15, 2013 12:12 am

GH wrote:If the early stuff ever does come out, it will be called A Few Really Fucking Old Tunes.

That actually sounds like I'm trying to be provocative or hostile, but I was merely being silly.

thepastinsidepressant · Fri Feb 15, 2013 1:29 am

Christ. is great, i know people like to listen to MBV on downtime and even more so now as they've just released a new album after 22 years but for me.... it's Christ. that's who i listen to for an outside fix and imo is the closest one will ever get and not MBV. They say their influenced by them yes, they drop name them, the lo-fi, the guitars etc etc but in sound and style Christ. is the man.

thepastinsidepressant · Fri Feb 15, 2013 1:31 am

mdg wrote:Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

Hello, any news?

zeoevil · Post by **zeoevil** » Fri Feb 15, 2013 3:12 am

mdg wrote:
zeoevil wrote:
harpoon dodger wrote:There are also unconfirmed reports (if you go back and read thru interviews, etc) saying that the very early releases (Catalog 3, Acid Memories, etc) featured a lineup of 6 or more members. Of course, the brothers themselves have not given any solid answers to this, and unless we ever get a proper release of that material, we probably never will.
At this point, I think it comes down to finding the other members and dealing with the legal ramifications of releasing the old material. If they just threw it out there all willy-nilly, they could open themselves up to trouble. They might not even be able to find some of those people so the possibility that we might hear all of Duffy or Infinite Sevens or "insert your favorite here" is effectively null.

Any and all early material by BOC was 100% written by Mike Sandison & Marcus Eoin. There's absolutely no question of "legal" regarding the BOC back-catalogue, and any hold-up with remastering or curating early work has been purely down to the time involved!

Maybe they could just throw us a bone or something?