[Interview] Humo (July 16th, 2013) + Poll

bluesky · Post by **Fredd-E** » Sat Aug 10, 2013 7:19 am

WeHadNormality wrote:
Fredd-E wrote:added a poll to the opening post
Semena Mertvykh has been missed off the poll.

woops, fixed it!

Keeoaddi · Post by **Keeoaddi** » Sat Aug 10, 2013 6:54 pm

must be nothing is real. being honest it's the only one that bears any resemblance to their old days, the others have more sophistication and layering, and don't have such a strong hinge on that simple melodic-ness of the early stuff.

Cupz · Post by **Cupz** » Sun Aug 11, 2013 9:20 pm

my best bet is palace posy, though cold earth is up there.

ArbitersGround · Post by **ArbitersGround** » Mon Aug 12, 2013 4:33 am

My vote goes to Semena Mertvykh. A lot of the tracks sort of reprise different elements of other tracks, whether it's something with production or composition (like the synth arpeggios or), or a lot of the tracks just seem too well-produced to be from their old days. Semena Mertvykh is the one I can picture the most off of Old Tunes or one of those albums.

Pretzel · Post by **Pretzel** » Sun Feb 16, 2014 9:29 am

“Collapse” has a melody embedded in it (starting around 1:06) that’s almost identical to the melody from Old Tunes v1 side B Audio track 16:

If you play Collapse and then play audio track 16 back-to-back the similarities become apparent.

several · Post by **several** » Sun Feb 16, 2014 11:34 pm

it has to be palace posy. that track sounds SO much like something off old tunes...

ParticleGhost · Post by **ParticleGhost** » Mon Feb 17, 2014 5:01 am

Either Semena Mertvykh, or Jacquard Causeway

Pretzel · Post by **Pretzel** » Mon Feb 17, 2014 10:44 am

It's Collapse. I've never been more certain of anything. During a calm moment, have a listen to one followed by the other. It's really quite wonderful.

Goodnight everyone.

irv · Post by **irv** » Mon Feb 17, 2014 11:24 am

Pretzel wrote:It's Collapse. I've never been more certain of anything. During a calm moment, have a listen to one followed by the other. It's really quite wonderful.

Goodnight everyone.

Respect your opinion, but I disagree - mainly because of the arpeggio that's running through it which seems to me to be something quite new in this album.

I think it's Nothing Is Real, just sounds like a MHTRTC-era style track to me. Only other track I think it might be is Sundown which reminds of one of the chaps freeplaying on a keyboard a la Farewell Fire.

Edit: I've just listened to them both a lot and am veering closer to it being Sundown.

Fireal420 · Post by **Fireal420** » Wed Feb 19, 2014 1:29 am

honestly. i think we should narrow this thread down to. is it "palace posy" or "nothing is real"

one of these tracks has to be the one that goes back to their early days

the more i think about it though. the more i believe the track is nothing is real

it mainly just loops and doesnt go anywhere (not in a negative way, i love the song). but it seems like something the brothers could have composed when they were young. the vocal samples seem different than what we are used to from recent boc, and last but not least, the first time i ever heard tomorrows harvest, i immediately thought to myself when i heard nothing is real, this song really reminds me of their old school stuff.

arvy · Post by **arvy** » Wed Feb 19, 2014 10:29 am

It would be awesome if it's Nothing is Real, just because I think it's a great track and seems they don't release it for a very long time, also the lyrics, it's like a poetry for me

irv · Post by **irv** » Wed Feb 19, 2014 12:00 pm

Fireal420 wrote:the first time i ever heard tomorrows harvest, i immediately thought to myself when i heard nothing is real, this song really reminds me of their old school stuff.

Yeah me too - thought immediately of Roygbiv.

Decorah · Post by **Decorah** » Wed Feb 19, 2014 3:34 pm

I'd be surprised if it was anything but Nothing is Real. I can see it being Palace Posy too, but perhaps an earlier less refined version. Nothing is Real could fit right into Old Tunes without anyone batting an eye (ear).

PS I love every song BoC has ever done in the history of ever.

Dudeman162 · Post by **Dudeman162** » Fri Feb 21, 2014 1:53 pm

Semena Mertvhk is the oldest sounding track in the album, yet people are going for Nothing is Real because it sounds like Roygbiv.

irv · Post by **irv** » Fri Feb 21, 2014 3:10 pm

Can't see it being Semena Mertvykh in any way personally.

Far darker and moodier than anything else they've done imo.

seanandcandy · Post by **seanandcandy** » Sat Feb 22, 2014 8:58 am

speaking of this magazine, does anyone have a physical copy

____twoism

[Interview] Humo (July 16th, 2013) + Poll

Which track dates back to their very early days?