vballs wrote:I wonder how these polls would turn out if instead of voting for the "least favourite", we voted for what we consider to be the least or most technically brilliant. For example, Music is Math is a lovely piece, I can see why it is the favorite for many but in my humble opinion, something like "Devil Is In The Details" trumps it in the genius department, it is a really fascinating piece, very clever indeed.
I feel like either The Devil is in the Details, Dawn Chorus, Corsair, or You Could Feel the Sky would win there.
Red -
Orange - Aquarius
Yellow - Alpha and Omega
Green -
Blue -
Purple - Music is Math
vballs wrote:I wonder how these polls would turn out if instead of voting for the "least favourite", we voted for what we consider to be the least or most technically brilliant. For example, Music is Math is a lovely piece, I can see why it is the favorite for many but in my humble opinion, something like "Devil Is In The Details" trumps it in the genius department, it is a really fascinating piece, very clever indeed.
Something like that is fine. No problem with polls and no problem with putting new thought into tracks, seeing them fresh. Something more constructive would probably appeal more to me though because most all of this isn't even discussion about the tracks. It's discussion about why people picked which tracks they did with phrases like "my word!" being thrown around every now and then.
I'm very surprised that Over The Horizon Radar is still in and Julie & Candy and Alpha & Omega are out. Granted, Music Is Math is a very good piece and I knew that it would make it to the end. I'm indifferent about Sunshine Recorder. Also still getting over the fact 1969 and TDIITD were voted out so early!
Top three for me would probably be Alpha And Omega/TDIITD/either Julie And Candy, 1969 or The Beach At Redpoint. In all honesty the whole of Geogaddi is perfect for me (except maybe Side E).
pigammon wrote:In all honesty the whole of Geogaddi is perfect for me (except maybe Side E).
Not liking the side with Dawn Chorus, Diving Station, You Could Feel The Sky and Corsair?! Crazy
Corsair is amazing, Dawn Chorus is pretty great as well although not a 10/10 like most of the other tracks imo. The other two are kind of a let down, but no album is perfect.
