____twoism

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 1:10 pm**

Hey guys, Youtube just recommended this for me. Can anyone shed some light? Is it a fake?

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=P ... faR6oxxFtv

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 4:01 pm**

Some are real, some are fake, and some are just mislabeled. There's nothing new or yet undiscovered though:

1. Fake - sounds like it could be Davefrom2001 though, I don't remember
2. Macquarie Ridge (real, Campfire Headphase Japanese bonus track)
3. Parks Canada Commercial (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKpfPjX1El0)
4. Last Walk Around Mirror Lake (real, remix of Boom Bip)
5. Buckie High (real, Old Tunes Vol 2)
6. Fake - DaveFrom2001 - Kids for Today (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_04iBLEc16E)
7. Poppy Seed (reprise) -- (real, misnamed)
8. Fake - Freescha - Isotopes (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AN9WYiOXXgc)
9. Fake - Freescha - Up the Coast (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-49a3qTDO4o)
10. R35TT - Audiotrack 9b (real,misnamed)
11. Fake (Don't remember real source, im sure someone here knows though)
12. Duffy Extract (real, taken from old cosmic crofter site)
13. She is P (real, misnamed, AFOT)
14. Fake (unknown)
15. Sequoia (real, AFOT)
16. Breaking Nehushtan (real, Old Tunes Vol 2)
17. Seven Forty Seven (real, Old website extract)
18. Poppy Seed reprise - fan edit (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4tTKITTfK0)
19. Its definitely Alpha Rainbow from Old Tunes Vol 2, but its been edited and I haven't heard this version before.
20. Fake (unknown)
21. Unconfirmed - I actually think this is real, but most think its fake. Its probably the only "fake" I actually think might be them.
22. Freescha - Kid Brother (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0IpwtkpX7w)

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 4:24 pm**

Thanks for that Helicoid! I recognised some of the mislabeled ones (Poppy Seed being called Children's Prision is not new) and the old tunes ones but since they don't have the same lenght as the ones we know I thought maybe they were different versions. Didn't heard anything by Freescha though so I didn't recognised those tracks. The only thing that stuck out for me was Macquaire Ridge being there but how cool would it be to discover it's an old track right?

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 4:30 pm**

Oh man, you had never heard Macquarie Ridge? I'm actually kinda jealous. One of my favorite by them. I wish I could go back and hear it again for the first time.

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 4:36 pm**

Yeah of course I heard Ridge, what I haven't heard before were the Freescha tracks

. What I said about Ridge was that if this playlist were indeed an old album, then it would mean that Macquaire was actually an old track included on that japanese TCH version and not a track recorded specifically for that album, and that was a very cool thought!

Posted: **Mon Mar 30, 2020 4:41 pm**

Ah ok I get you now! Yeah that would have been neat.

Posted: **Tue Mar 31, 2020 5:20 pm**

Helicoid wrote:11. Fake (Don't remember real source, im sure someone here knows though)
20. Fake (unknown)
21. Unconfirmed - I actually think this is real, but most think its fake. Its probably the only "fake" I actually think might be them.

11. Mislabeled: "Incandescent Autumn" by Chaosmachine. (https://watmmrecords.bandcamp.com/track ... ent-autumn)
20. Mislabeled: "Parson" is the name of an unreleased Marumari track.
21. Fake: This one is a very old (most likely) fake. I've never seen anyone identify the real title.

Posted: **Tue Mar 31, 2020 8:41 pm**

playbyletters wrote:
Helicoid wrote:11. Fake (Don't remember real source, im sure someone here knows though)
20. Fake (unknown)
21. Unconfirmed - I actually think this is real, but most think its fake. Its probably the only "fake" I actually think might be them.

11. Mislabeled: "Incandescent Autumn" by Chaosmachine. (https://watmmrecords.bandcamp.com/track ... ent-autumn)
20. Mislabeled: "Parson" is the name of an unreleased Marumari track.
21. Fake: This one is a very old (most likely) fake. I've never seen anyone identify the real title.

Hey! thanks for that. I should have known #11 was Chaosmachine. I had never heard the unreleased Marumari track though, good call. As far as #21, I really want to believe. Its been floating around for ages labelled as "Focus on the Spiral" and is usually accompanied by "Helios Sound" and "Close3". Out of all the fakes that have ever surfaced, I actually think these may be legit. They are also (as far as I know) the only ones that have never been officially disproven/debunked, despite how long they have been around. Also, the tracklengths seem to match perfectly.

Speaking of these songs, Close3 has a sample in it that says "He says the sun came out last night. He says it sang to him.". I believe RoughTrade tweeted that during the whole Tomorrow's Harvest release campaign thing. This "fake" surfaced way before then and I don't know of any other Close Encounters references in BoC's works. I definitely believe.

Posted: **Tue Mar 31, 2020 8:51 pm**

Helicoid wrote:
playbyletters wrote:
Helicoid wrote:11. Fake (Don't remember real source, im sure someone here knows though)
20. Fake (unknown)
21. Unconfirmed - I actually think this is real, but most think its fake. Its probably the only "fake" I actually think might be them.

11. Mislabeled: "Incandescent Autumn" by Chaosmachine. (https://watmmrecords.bandcamp.com/track ... ent-autumn)
20. Mislabeled: "Parson" is the name of an unreleased Marumari track.
21. Fake: This one is a very old (most likely) fake. I've never seen anyone identify the real title.

Hey! thanks for that. I should have known #11 was Chaosmachine. I had never heard the unreleased Marumari track though, good call. As far as #21, I really want to believe. Its been floating around for ages labelled as "Focus on the Spiral" and is usually accompanied by "Helios Sound" and "Close3". Out of all the fakes that have ever surfaced, I actually think these may be legit. They are also (as far as I know) the only ones that have never been officially disproven/debunked, despite how long they have been around. Also, the tracklengths seem to match perfectly.

Speaking of these songs, Close3 has a sample in it that says "He says the sun came out last night. He says it sang to him.". I believe RoughTrade tweeted that during the whole Tomorrow's Harvest release campaign thing. This "fake" surfaced way before then and I don't know of any other Close Encounters references in BoC's works. I definitely believe.

https://twitter.com/RoughTrade/status/3 ... 4717120512

____twoism

The Children's Prision

The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision

Re: The Children's Prision