If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one album

Moderators: Aesthetics, Drones, Hexagon Sun

Post a reply
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one album

Post by clear blue water »

Which would it be?

Geogaddi is the album I'd lose. It is an exceptionally brilliant album but it just doesn't gel with the others in my opinion. It's the oddity in their back catalogue. There's a sequential uniformity between MHTTFC and TCFH with the EPs bridging these two masterpieces.
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by clear blue water »

Also I'm not a fan of anything "dark" or that is self-consciously marketed as dark. Everything has to be "dark" (woo woo woo) nowadays. Give me Bucks Fizz anyday.
vitriolie

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by vitriolie »

The campfire headphase?
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by clear blue water »

vitriolie wrote:The campfire headphase?
Their best album, so no.
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by clear blue water »

clear blue water wrote:Which would it be?

Geogaddi is the album I'd lose. It is an exceptionally brilliant album but it just doesn't gel with the others in my opinion. It's the oddity in their back catalogue. There's a sequential uniformity between MHTRTC and TCFH with the EPs bridging these two masterpieces.
vitriolie

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by vitriolie »

clear blue water wrote:
vitriolie wrote:The campfire headphase?
Their best album, so no.
It is good, but not as layered and complex as others. Feels like an afterthought to me. What the fans of the bro'z would dig, if they want more BoC.
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by clear blue water »

vitriolie wrote:
clear blue water wrote:
vitriolie wrote:The campfire headphase?
Their best album, so no.
It is good, but not as layered and complex as others. Feels like an afterthought to me. What the fans of the bro'z would dig, if they want more BoC.
That's why I love it. It's nothing unexpected. It does precisely what it says on the tin.
vitriolie

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by vitriolie »

Excellent choice of taste.
User avatar
clear blue water
Friendly Stranger
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2025 1:03 pm

Re: If you had to thin BoC back catalogue by removing one al

Post by clear blue water »

vitriolie wrote:Excellent choice of taste.
Thank you.
Post a reply